Showing posts with label fate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fate. Show all posts

Tuesday, 11 May 2010

Chassidic Planets


Joseph Roth’s literature comes from the East, from the border of a great empire where miracles and storytellers belong to the everyday world.  He was a “Badchan”, the eastern Jewish combination of joker, fool, philosopher and storyteller.  But he was also a realist in the sense of Balzac and “Thousand and One Nights” for whom the detail is not a symbol, but rather itself the concrete totality. 

In a short tribute to a fellow “Kolporteur”, Egon Erwin Kisch, Roth expresses the intention of his own poetics: “Egon Erwin Kisch is not a roving reporter; that is only a nickname, that he gave himself not without self-irony; he is a conscientious and profound journalist.  What makes him a superb writer and his reportage – a literary oeuvre, is – the materialist Kisch will hopefully forgive me – the grace, the grace of the true writer, which consists in a way of describing reality, without injuring the truth; that despite the documentary reality one does not neglect the truth.” (Joseph Roth, Prague, 1934)       
(“Egon Erwin Kisch ist kein rasender Reporter; das ist ein Spitzname, den er sich nicht ohne Selbstironie gegeben hat; er ist ein gewissenhafter und gründlicher Berichterstatter.  Was ihn aber zum vorzüglichen Schriftsteller macht und seine Berichterstattungen zu literarischen Werken, ist – der Materialist Kisch möge es mir nachsehen - die Gnade, die Gnade des echten Schriftstellers, die darin besteht, daß man die Wirklichkeit beschreibt, ohne die Wahrheit zu verletzen; daß man trotz der dokumentarischen Wirklichkeit nicht versäumt, die Wahrheit zu sagen.” Joseph Roth Werke, Band IV, Amsterdam, 1975, p. 286)

One hears a Hegelian phenomenology in this brief credo – the truth is real, reality is not necessarily the truth.  Roth’s narrative truth does not however lie in an exemplification of a philosophy of history.  Rather it is below – the subversive unwritten manuscripts of “stillen Dichter” (silent poets) – in the shabby world of the eastern Jewish small town (Shtetl) and its saving Chassidic graces.  His wisdom resides in the secret knowledge of the powerless, of the slaves, that behind every mask of power are the grimaces of Job.  “Also you are Job”, whispered the old man called “Heiliger Vater” (Holy Father) to Napoleon after Waterloo in Roth’s “Die Hundert Tage” (The Hundred Days).  The recognition of forms of misfortune is a privilege of the weak.  This tale appears from its other end in Ernst Bloch’s “Spuren”.  Bloch quotes an eastern Jewish story meant as a joke, only because its earnestness belies an uncanny vertigo in the seamless plane. 

The story entitled “Fall ins Jetzt” (Fall in Now) in “Spuren” goes as follows:
Some Jews were conversing in a prayer house in a small town.  They were discussing what each one would wish if an angel were to appear.  The rabbi said he would wish to be rid of his cough.  I wish I would marry off my daughter, said the second.  A third wished he did not have a daughter, but rather a son who could take over his business.  Finally the rabbi turned to a beggar sitting on the bench in the back and asked what his desire was – for certainly he did not look like he was without a wish.  The beggar’s wish takes the form of an imaginary chronicle leading up to the present.  I wish, said he, I were a great king like King Solomon but without his luck in war.  My armies are defeated, my cities and forests are set on fire, the enemy is at the gates of my palace with its onyx, marble and sandalwood.  I am alone in the throne room with sceptre and crown, deserted by my court and nobles, I hear the people in the streets crying out for my blood.  I must flee the enemies invading my land with nothing but the shirt on my back, I cross the border and mingle among people who do not know me and am saved, “(…) und seit gestern abend sitze ich hier.” (“and since yesterday evening I am sitting here”, Ernst Bloch, Spuren, Frankfurt, 1983, p. 99)  The rabbi is perturbed by this wish in which again the beggar loses everything.  The beggar interjects – I would have something, the shirt on my back.

Bloch emphasizes the interaction of a dream past and the present – the convolutions introduced by the wish-form as a historical conjecture with an ending in the ‘real’ present.  This is however the essence of the storyteller, the epic ballad – the fictive past is transformed by its telling in the present.  The present harbours all possible pasts as its story, not unlike the intervention of the dream in reality.  As de Nerval says: “Le rêve est une seconde vie.”  Cervantes placed both dream and reality in the present.  The dream images of Don Quixote do not make him ridiculous – his dreams derisively reveal the material squalor of the world through which Don Quixote rides blinded by dreams.  The blindness to a ‘documentary reality’ enables the vision of another reality.  The supposed insanity of the hero of Gustav Meyrink’s “The Golem”, his sensual perception of “Grauen” (horror), is expressive of the ghetto’s most tangible form – the room without the door.

Roth, eastern Jewish K.u.K loyalist, ‘hanging on Franz Joseph’s sideburns’ (Itzik Manger) reflects another mythological truth, that of the German fairy tales.  His Napoleon is the emperor of the people, chosen and crowned by them.  He is the Volkskaiser, the sleeping emperor, who will awaken for the final victory to free the poor and oppressed.  An erotic bond exists between the people and their redeemer.  Without this belief the beggar just sits there – the present collapses into itself.  He is a naked vulnerable Job without a past and therefore without a future. 

Roth shared the longings for messianic redemption of eastern European Chassidism.  He remained a son of the Shtetl, home of those strange figures without an address and visible occupation who people his novels and whose historical limitations he described most aptly.  They were also his own.  “Der arme Jude ist der konservativste Mensch unter allen Armen der Welt.  Er ist geradezu eine Garantie für die Erhaltung der alten Gesellschaftsordnung.” (“The poor Jew is the most conservative person amongst all the poor of the world.  He is the perfect guarantee for the preservation of the old social order.” Joseph Roth, “Juden auf Wanderschaft”, Werke, Band III, Amsterdam, 1975, p. 321)  This conservatism was perhaps the greatest misfortune of the nation of Jobs.  Messianic transcendentalism was only exceeded by fatalism and submissiveness in daily life.  Chiliastic redemption was a local rumour, possibly true in the next town but never in one’s own.

The names of Kisch, Meyrink and Bloch manifest the perimeter of Roth’s narrative world.  Like them, he charts the fluctuations of an objective cruel fate –Glück und Unglück (happiness and unhappiness, luck and unluckiness), power and powerlessness, master and slave – but always leaving a crevice for a wish or a joke or a Houdini like escape.  Roth saw not only the existing and coming destruction of the world into which he was born.  He was not only a beggar with just a shirt on his back.  The truth of Job is also the turn of fate, a redemption which infuses the vagaries of ordinary people with cosmological design.  “As long as there is still one beggar around, there will still be myth.” (“Solange es noch einen Bettler gibt, solange gibt es noch Mythos.” Walter Benjamin, Das Passagen-Werk, Frankfurt, 1983, [K 6, 4], p. 505)
 
 
 
 
 




                   

Thursday, 8 April 2010

Norman Habits


Fate seems to reside upon habits.  Habits are stronger than truth, because their sheer persistence seems to defy refutation.  They appear to self-verify through daily or regular use.  Like a scientific procedure, habits are repeatable with the same or similar results.  But they are also like fate as they conduct you in their repetitive cyclical fashion incrementally along your unalterable inexorable route.

Aristotle calls habits hexis, although this word has many interpretations  - it usually refers to a ‘state’ which is nearly permanent, a kind of second nature.  Habits increase the general level of predictability in human life, as quasi-individual conventions they acquire the status of instinct.  In Aristotle’s Metaphysics hexis is opposed to energeia (activity or operation) – as whatever energy once entered the creation of a habit is thoroughly digested in the shortest of time. 

I have lost my habit of reading at the breakfast table – although I used to learn all sorts of useless information from it.  In particular about habits.  Habitual activities tend to produce habitual results.  Losing the habit may have increased my stock of energeia, or at least demonstrates that one can reverse the flow of nature or quasi-nature.  I never tried to lose the habit - it was probably driven out by a new and stronger habit.  Nietzsche advocates “short habits” thinking that one could distract a repeated action from becoming a habit by cutting it short.  A habit does rely on the temporal dimension but its shortness is no guarantee against its fullness or longevity.  Indeed it is within the realm of conceivability that a habit takes place only once.  Everything else about Nietzsche was long or at least not short.  His thought would be finally thought through in a thousand years, no philosophical system big enough to contain it.
He clung to friendship and family like a Virginia creeper, and one knows there is nothing one can do to annihilate those plants.  Most indestructible of all is his euphoria, it is no short habit.  Habits have the virtue of not always being in evidence; they are discreet if largely recurrent.
A lost cause is also a habit – any fidelity to such a cause merely rehearses a played out melodrama.
Something which is always there, like gaiety, is certainly not a habit, but it is not short either.  Aristotle would have referred to such a semi-permanent state as hexis as well.  But this is confusing.  Something which is always there, never goes away, needs no cause, in this case groundless good cheer, lacks the sine qua non of hexis – privation or a time in which the habit is in abeyance.  No matter how long a habit, even an infinite one – a habit (whatever size, quantity) will never reach “the sharpest point of infinity”. (“la pointe… plus acérée… de l’Infini”, Baudelaire)

One is lucky if one is able to choose to give up one’s habits, more likely the years will take them away, as one can learn from Horace.  “Each year of life as it passes takes something away from us as its prey: they have bereaved me of jest and game, they have deducted wine and kisses and now they wrestle the lyre from my hand, what else do you want?” (“Singula de nobis anni praedantur euntes; eripuere jocos, venerem, convivial, ludum; tendent extorquere poemata: qid faciam vis?” Letter to Julius Florus, Horazens Briefe, translated and edited by C.M. Wieland, Nördlingen, 1986, p. 508)

Once at the breakfast table I learned an old Norman rhyme about habits.
“lever a cinq, diner a neuf,
souper a cinq, coucher a neuf
fait vivre dans nonant et neuf.”
(rise at five, dine at nine,
sup at five, to bed at nine,
you’ll live to be ninety nine.”)
The Normans in Britain lived in their castles according to this strict routine.  Their habits distinguished them from the Saxons whom they conquered.  Were their habits instrumental to this conquest?  The historian G. Macaulay Trevelyan calls them “methodical barbarians”, suggesting they were people of strong habits but not civilised.  Life in a Norman castle was not very refined.  The habit of cooking everything in a pie is at least 6oo years old, as is the use of ginger as flavouring.  Recipes tended to hew everything to dust (hens and pork together) mix with breadcrumbs and egg yolk and boil.  Retainers of both sexes slept in a hall on rushes around a fire.  Everything seems dirtier and less comfortable than in the palaces of Ulysses or Menelaus.  The Saxons were in awe of these sombre piles – never having seen a castle before the Normans arrived on the island.  “The Saxons were slow and difficult to move: they were farmers and herdsmen, who did not mind fighting, if their crops were in and they had nothing to do; and it was difficult to keep them together as an army, unless the call for their services were very urgent.  They (…) thought very little about Art, or Literature and, so long as their neighbours left them alone, showed little interest in other people’s doings.  Saxons lacked the art of combination, and it was because of this they failed against the Normans.” - according to an illustrated children’s book published in 1918. (Marjorie and C.D.B. Quennell, A History of Everyday Things in England, London, 1918,
p. 2)

It occurred to me that a few hundred years before William the Conqueror came from France to trounce the dull-witted artless brutal Saxons another Frank (William was a Norman but ‘Frankified’) massacred and subjugated the Saxons on the continent during a kind of medieval Verdun.  The other Frank was Charlemagne.  The Saxons were so easy to beat because they had learned nothing from the Romans about fortifications.  They tore down all the walled cities or settlements built by the Romans in Britain.  They did not like being confined, preferring to live in clearings in the woods, near their fields.  They only knew how to swarm out in hordes but had little perseverance and only enough engineering to erect some flimsy wooden palisades.  Their idea of fortification was to dig long ditches – like the trench warfare of World War One.  The battle was fought already halfway into the grave.  The Normans fought from above – from the castle mount, on top of which was the keep, on horseback with spear and sword.  The Saxons were as helpless as the Incas or Aztecs (who had a higher civilisation) at the appearance of the conquistadors.  Whether they heeded the cold ‘bells of Angelus’ or warmed themselves at the fire of Woden’s blood sacrifice – all the Saxons succumbed to the Norman habit.  Even before the Norman invasion – the bells used to lead the Danish ‘host’ to where the unmapped Saxon settlements were nestling amongst the trees.
The place where Charlemagne had the Saxons slaughtered was Verden – renowned as the Massacre of Verden of 782.  Later in 843 the Treaty of Verdun divided the Frankish Empire between the three surviving sons of Louis the Pious, son of Charlemagne into Middle Francia, East Francia and West Francia.